When I reported on Carriage’s earnings call earlier this month I wondered about some of the underpinnings of the company’s miss and whether it had much to do with their new M&A approach. Not long after, I got to speak with Steve Metzger, Carriage president and COO about the timing behind Carriage’s lowered full-year 2026 guidance, the localized friction in its California cemeteries, and why the company refuses to enter a race to the bottom on direct cremation pricing.
Acquisition Timing and Guidance
During the third-quarter earnings call, Carriage trimmed their full-year 2026 revenue outlook to a range of $415 million to $420 million, citing softer cemetery preneed property sales, a discrete $2.5 million trust-related tax expense, and later-than-anticipated closing dates for pending acquisitions.
While Carriage holds over $14 million in annualized revenue under contract or letter of intent across five separate transactions, most of that will not register until the new year. Metzger explained that building anticipated acquisition revenue into the initial 2026 guidance was a forecasting approach the company plans to retire.
“The thing that we did this year that we won’t do moving forward is we built in anticipated revenue from acquisitions into the guidance and that was really based on kind of our historical run rate in a typical year,” Metzger said. “What we learned this year was just timing for the types of businesses we like and the owners that we were talking to. Their timing was just a little bit delayed and we’re not gonna rush them.”
It’s worth remembering that the company only recently installed a more methodical approach to M&A, so it’s as if the old numbers didn’t fit the new attitude. As state regulators complete their reviews, the company expects to close one or two deals in December generating $100,000 to $200,000, with the bulk of the transactions closing in the first quarter of 2027.
One disconnect I didn’t quite get resolved was the difference in volumes. SCI said that volumes were down because of death rates. Carriage’s volume was up on the same death rates. While he admitted Carriage had a better volume story than its competitor, he attributed it to regional difficulties.
On the M&A approach, though, he reiterated something that Carriage has been touting since the beginning of their turnaround. The company said recently that, barring the unforeseen, it is done with divestitures. I asked him about some of the contraction we’re seeing as consolidators pick up multiple businesses in the same market.
“When we acquire a new business that has multiple rooftops, typically they’re pretty well spread out,” he said. “And so it’s not often we need to make those types of changes.”
Cemetery Sales: Macro Pressures and ‘Blocking and Tackling’
On the cemetery side, year-to-date preneed property sales in California fell 7.1 percent, dragging down an otherwise strong 10.1 percent gain across Carriage’s remaining markets. Metzger attributed the California shortfall to a combination of consumer belt-tightening and internal execution gaps.
“People are really impacted right now, whether it’s at the pump or at the grocery store or wherever else,” Metzger said. “Those discretionary dollars have become more precious this year just because of the environment. It’s a tougher environment this year versus last year to compete for those discretionary dollars in cemetery preneed property. It’s nice to have for people.”
To turn the tide, leadership is focusing on what Metzger called “cemetery sales 101” aimed at refocussing on the basics from the top down. That means, increasing sales counselor headcount, refining lead generation, and ensuring teams use the new sales tools.
Notably, the slump is isolated to entry-level contracts. While Vice Chairman and CEO Carlos Quezada previously pointed out deficits in contracts priced below $20,000, Metzger confirmed that high-end cemetery sales are actually outperforming the prior year, trending higher in line with the company’s capital allocations for large-scale inventory development.
“We’re actually up year over year on large sales,” Metzger said. “We’re not seeing any pressure on the large sales. That’s why I think it’s really some of those entry point sales that we need to be more focused on.”
Even with the regional headwinds, Metzger kept the overall performance in perspective.
“The good news for us is we’re about flat for the year,” he said. “That’s not good enough for us, but it’s also not broken when it’s flat.”
Holding the Line on Direct Cremation
As funeral contract volume ticked upward in the third quarter, Carriage also increased its average revenue per funeral contract by $109. That growth reflects a deliberate refusal to chase low-margin volume through standalone, low-cost direct cremation brands.
“We’re not going to play the price race to the bottom game of $799, $699 direct cremation,” Metzger said. “We’ll still try and get those direct cremation calls in, but we’re going to charge a rate that we think is reflective of the value we provide, and we’re not a direct disposer, we’re not a storefront. And that’s not a model that we’re really looking to expand upon.”
Instead, when families seeking direct cremation visit a Carriage funeral home, staff focus on educating them about memorialization options, services, and keepsakes without pressuring them. If a family still opts for direct cremation, Metzger said, Carriage is glad to serve them at its established price point.
Looking toward the end of the fourth quarter and the start of 2027, Metzger emphasized that Carriage is prioritizing sustainable execution over rapid, reactive moves.
“We’ve got a strong foundation,” Metzger said. “I think we’re patient, we’re selective on how we grow. Our story is not always going to be as fast as everybody wants to see it, but it is going to be thoughtful, and we think it’s going to be responsible and just excited to close the year strong and head into 2027 with some momentum.”

