Pennsylvania Funeral Directors Awaiting Decision From High Court
Article originally appeared on Daily Local, Pittsburgh
PITTSBURGH >> The U.S. Supreme Court will decide this fall whether to hear a case concerning an alleged “antiquated,” “protectionist regime” in Pennsylvania’s death industry.
Those bringing the case say it could affect all Americans. The case also highlights some ugly realities about our government structure.
“The Constitution does not protect against inefficient, wasteful, or meaningless legislation. ‘(A) law may exact a needless, wasteful requirement in many cases. But it is for the legislature, not the courts, to balance the advantages and disadvantages of the requirement.’”
While that reality may seem harsh, that’s separation of powers in action.
Sevgi Tekeli, a clerk in the U.S. Supreme Court, said it’s uncertain whether the justices would hear the case. That decision will come in October, when its session begins.
The case pits a group of 20 funeral home directors, funeral home owners, businesses and others against what they allege is an outdated system that imposes requirements that are unnecessary, protectionist and ultimately increase prices for consumers.
In May 2012, federal Judge John E. Jones III partially ruled in their favor, finding in his 159-page opinion that many of the rules governing funeral homes in Pennsylvania were antiquated and amounted to a “protectionist regime.” He threw out rules requiring embalming rooms for each facility, prohibiting food in funeral homes and allowing random inspections, among others.
When the State Board of Funeral Directors appeared to do little in reaction to his ruling, Jones issued a scathing memorandum, calling its conduct “the very epitome of bad faith.”
“That the Board would cling to a law that is so outdated and patently unconstitutional in so many ways is as embarrassing as it is unconscionable. Frankly, the members of the Board should be ashamed of themselves,” the justice wrote.
Unfortunately for the plaintiffs, the 3rd Circuit disagreed and found the lower court had essentially used the wrong standard in reviewing the regulations.
“We surmise that much of the District Court’s conclusions regarding the constitutionality of the (Funeral Directors Law), enacted in 1952, stem from a view that certain provisions of the FDL are antiquated in light of how funeral homes now operate. That is not, however, a constitutional flaw,” wrote the 3rd Circuit.
Ernie Heffner, lead plaintiff in the case, said, “This particular matter has an impact on all sorts of people, and not just people in need of after-death care,” he said.
The Institute for Justice is providing legal assistance to the plaintiffs. In a July news release, its lawyers discuss this broad impact. In the case, they want the Supreme Court to decide that, in order for regulations to be constitutional, the reason for them must be “rational today” — that it’s not enough that the rules were “rational in theory when passed long ago in a world that was a much different place.”
Because of this broader issue, the plaintiffs say they are hopeful the Supreme Court will hear the case. Heffner said he’s “guardedly optimistic.”
Kathleen Ryan, general counsel for the Pennsylvania Funeral Directors Association, said the plaintiffs face an uphill battle getting the case to the Supreme Court.
Ryan said the PFDA doesn’t necessarily intend to try to get new laws passed by the Legislature, both because “members are 50-50” on most of the issues and because when you ask for new legislation, “you never know what you’re going to get.”
With the current system, “it may not be perfect, but it works.”
Martin can be reached at [email protected] , and follow her @RMartinWatchdog for more.
Latest posts by CDFuneralNews (see all)
- Download Our FREE Memorial Day Video - May 24, 2018
- FrontRunner Unveils its New ‘Final Resting Place’, GPS Enabled App - May 24, 2018
- StoneMor Partners Names Inman Shipping Worldwide as Preferred Shipping Provider - May 22, 2018
You may be interested
Download Our FREE Memorial Day VideoCDFuneralNews - May 24, 2018
Finding the right Memorial Day content to express your gratitude and honoring those who have fallen for our country can…
FrontRunner Unveils its New ‘Final Resting Place’, GPS Enabled AppCDFuneralNews - May 24, 2018
FrontRunner today announced the unveiling of the new GPS enabled App, Final Resting Place, which allows funeral homes, cemeteries and…
Learn How Your Funeral Home Can Offer Natural Burials in The Green Burial GuidebookJustin Crowe - May 23, 2018
The Green Burial Guidebook is a new book by Elizabeth Fournier explaining the methods and ideas behind having an affordable, environmentally…