Parents Sue Facebook Over Online Corpse Photo
STATEN ISLAND, N.Y. — Their daughter?s brutal murder crushed them, and a Rosebank couple?s grief only grew when an emergency medical technician posted photos of her badly beaten corpse on Facebook.
Their emotions still raw yesterday, two years to the day that Caroline Wimmer was slain, Martha and Ronald Wimmer announced they have sued Facebook, the social networking site; Mark Musarella, the emergency medical technician who posted the photo; the city; the apartment complex where their daughter lived, and others.
“I?m just very upset and traumatized over all this,” said Mrs. Wimmer, of Rosebank, fighting back tears on the steps of state Supreme Court, St. George. “I haven?t had a chance to heal yet. This is the second anniversary. We really need to improve our laws in New York. … My daughter?s picture was on the Internet and I can?t get it back.”
Prosecutors said Brooklyn resident Calvin Lawson killed Ms. Wimmer, 26, on March 28, 2009, over allegations that she?d told his girlfriend, the mother of his two children, that he was cheating on her with another woman.
Her parents found her lifeless body two days later in her Greenleaf Avenue home. She had been beaten and strangled with the cord of a hair dryer.
Musarella, who responded to the apartment on March 30, 2009, on a radio call, snapped a photo with his BlackBerry of Ms. Wimmer?s corpse. Afterward, he posted the shot on his Facebook.com page.
The suit seeks unspecified monetary damages from most of the defendants, but only injunctive relief from Facebook.
The Wimmers? lawyer, Ravi Batra of Manhattan, said federal law provides Facebook “absolute immunity” as a “supposed … nonprofit community bulletin board” from being sued for cash compensation.
He said his clients seek the return of any images of their daughter uploaded onto Facebook databases and the subsequent destruction of those images by Facebook. They also want the identities of any Facebook users who accessed or downloaded Ms. Wimmer?s photos.
“To know those pictures are on Facebook for anyone to see kills me,” said Christina Criscitiello, the victim?s older sister, her voice cracking. “She was brutally beaten. I feel like Mark Musarella took the last shred of dignity she had left. I can?t get those images out of my head. and I don?t want anybody else to see them.”
Latest posts by CDFuneralNews (see all)
- Physicians Mutual Celebrates Preneed Anniversary with NFDA Sponsorship - August 9, 2017
- The Only Good Aftercare Program Is A Consistent One - August 7, 2017
- OGR’s 2nd Annual Charitable Foundation Funeral Feud Event In Boston Includes NFDA Events - August 7, 2017
You may be interested
12 Benefits of Social Media Every Funeral Home Needs to KnowRyan Thogmartin - August 10, 2017
Social media is 'marketing.' It's not the new marketing, it's the current state of marketing, and funeral homes and death care companies can no longer afford to ignore it. There are so many reasons why death care companies need to get their heads out of the sand and start engaging on the platforms used by over 68% of all Americans.
Six Times Twitter Reminded Us Funerals Don’t Have to be BoringMadison Ashby - August 9, 2017
These six people had funerals on their mind for one reason or another and decided to share with the Twitter world what they were thinking, and I’m pretty glad they did. People can come up with some pretty crazy things if you let them ramble.
Physicians Mutual Celebrates Preneed Anniversary with NFDA SponsorshipCDFuneralNews - August 9, 2017
OMAHA – It’s been an exciting summer for Physicians Mutual, and the fun keeps on coming: the Company will celebrate…